Citizen Mint

Citizen Mint


Unlocking the Power of Your 401k: A Deep Dive into Traditional vs. Roth Contributions


Your 401k plan is more than just a savings account, it’s a dynamic and flexible vehicle for financial growth and stability. When employed correctly, it offers not just significant savings for your retirement years but also notable tax benefits. But to make the most of these advantages, you need to understand financial topics like the difference between traditional (pre-tax) and Roth (post-tax) contributions, and how to choose the right approach for you.

Traditional vs. Roth Contributions: The Basics

Most employers offer both traditional and Roth 401k accounts. Here’s the core difference:

  1. Traditional (Pre-Tax) Contributions: These contributions are deducted before income taxes are calculated, which reduces your current tax liability. However, when you withdraw the funds in retirement, you’ll have to pay taxes on both the contributions and the earnings.

  2. Roth (After-Tax) Contributions: These contributions are deducted after income taxes have been calculated, meaning they don’t lower your present tax bill. But the real benefit comes during retirement, when you can withdraw the funds entirely tax-free.

Choosing between a traditional or Roth 401k depends largely on your expectations about your future tax rate compared to your current tax rate.

Making the Right Choice: Future Tax Predictions

Making the right choice between traditional or Roth 401k contributions is, in large part, a strategic game of predicting your future tax situation. It’s about looking into your financial crystal ball and making the best educated guess about what your tax landscape will look like when you retire, compared to where it stands now.

Consider this scenario: If you’re in the early years of your career, chances are your income bracket is relatively modest, and consequently, so is your tax rate. In this situation, choosing a Roth 401k often makes more sense. Your contributions will be taxed at your current lower rate, and then, you can enjoy those retirement distributions tax-free, regardless of whether tax rates have skyrocketed in the interim.

Furthermore, it’s essential to take into account the economic climate and trends. Currently, we’re experiencing historically low tax rates. But with rising national debt, it’s reasonable to foresee a future where tax rates could be significantly higher. If such a scenario materializes, those who chose to lock in their tax rate today with Roth contributions could find themselves with a significant advantage.

Ultimately, it’s about using the information available to you now to make the most informed decision possible for your future financial health. That said, predicting future tax rates is certainly a challenge and, while it’s an important consideration, it shouldn’t be the only factor guiding your 401k strategy.

Exploring the Details: Specific Scenarios

Traditional Contributions Could be Better If:

  • Your 401k contributions would decrease without the immediate tax savings because you need that extra money now.

Roth After-Tax Might be Better:

  • If you want to avoid potential Social Security taxes, since Roth distributions aren’t factored into Social Security taxation calculations like pre-tax contributions are.
  • If your earnings disqualify you from making Roth IRA contributions.
  • If you plan to leave the account to your heirs, as an inherited Roth 401k won’t be subject to income tax.

The Contribution Limits

As of 2022, if you’re under 50, you can contribute up to $20,000 in total to both traditional and Roth 401k accounts (excluding any company match). If you’re 50 or older, you can make an additional catch-up contribution of $6,500, for a grand total of $26,500.

Navigating Roth 401k Distributions: When Are They Qualified?

When it comes to the world of Roth 401ks, there’s a particular term that you’ll frequently encounter: ‘Qualified Distributions’. But what exactly does this mean?

A ‘qualified distribution’ from a Roth 401k is one that is both tax-free and penalty-free. However, this advantageous treatment isn’t handed out freely. There are two key conditions that must be met before you can enjoy a qualified distribution:

  1. Five-Year Rule: The Roth 401k account from which you’re withdrawing must have been opened and funded for at least five years.
  2. Age or Circumstance Rule: The distribution must occur for one of three reasons – you’ve reached the age of 59 1/2, you’ve become disabled, or the distribution is made to your estate or beneficiary after your death.

It’s a nuanced part of the Roth 401k landscape, but understanding these criteria can help ensure you’re optimizing your tax-free benefits.

Balancing Your Approach: Pre vs. Post-Tax Contributions

A key factor in deciding between pre or post-tax accounts is the time until you expect to retire.

5-10 Years to Retirement:

  • Pre-tax contributions may be appealing if you believe your tax bracket will decrease, and you plan to utilize the money sooner.
  • Post-tax contributions might still be a good idea if you plan to let the money grow over a longer period, possibly for inheritance purposes.

10-20 Years to Retirement:

  • If you don’t have much in a Roth 401k, now is the time to start, for diversification and growth potential.
  • Consider converting some pre-tax savings to Roth, a move known as an In-Plan Conversion, for added tax benefits.

20+ Years to Retirement:

  • Pre-tax contributions could be useful if you need extra cash now, such as for a house down payment or to pay off student loans.
  • If you can afford it, Roth contributions offer the most benefits, given the substantial growth potential of tax-free compounding over a long period.

The Benefits of Back-door Roth Conversions

A Roth conversion lets you convert all or part of your traditional 401k to a Roth 401k. You can spread this conversion over several years to manage the tax impact and potentially convert in a year with lower earnings.

Please note, for a tax-free treatment on converted funds, you need to meet the following conditions:

  • You have to be at least 59 1/2 at the time of withdrawal.
  • It has to be at least five years since your first conversion or first Roth contribution.
With the right planning and understanding of these retirement strategies, you can set yourself up for a financially stable future, despite the potential for higher tax rates. Navigating your 401k options can be complex, but making the right decisions now can pave the way to a more comfortable retirement. So, whether it’s traditional or Roth, making an informed choice is the first step to maximizing your 401k.

Want to learn more?

Sign up to download Citizen Mint’s Investment Process & Philosophy white paper.


Learn how Citizen Mint simplifies private market investing

Sign up now to learn the benefits of private market impact investing for financial advisors

Get access now

Sign up now to access private market investments on Citizen Mint’s platform.